CarGarages.co.uk - Find Trusted Car Garages Near You
CarGarages

Car Problems Data
& Methodology

Analysing 559 million UK MOT tests across 20 years of DVSA data — the methodology behind every common car problem, MOT failure, and owner-reported issue we surface.

Sources: DVSA MOT Test Data + owner-submitted problems

559M+

MOT tests analysed

195M+

MOT failures recorded

190+

Car makes

2300+

Car models

3900+

Generations tracked

37K

Classified problem cards

20 years

Of data (2005–2024)

99%

Statistical confidence

Where Our UK MOT Data Comes From

Two sources, one goal — the most accurate picture of common UK car problems.

Every page on this site combines two distinct data sources. The first is the DVSA's public MOT dataset559M+ anonymised tests across 20 years of UK roads, covering every car and van that's passed through the testing network since 2005. It's the most comprehensive picture of UK vehicle reliability that exists anywhere.

The second is real-world reports from UK car owners. MOT data is great for the issues a tester sees on a ramp once a year — but it can't tell us about a fault that's never failed an MOT, or a quirk that owners notice between tests. That's where the “Tell us about your problem” form comes in.

The rest of this page walks through how we turn raw DVSA records into the problem cards you see on every model and generation page — and how owner reports sit alongside them as a fourth, human signal.

The Scale: 20 Years of UK MOT Tests

A year-by-year view of every MOT test we've processed (2005 excluded — partial data). Hover a bar for the pass/fail split.

Passes
Failures
2006
24M (35.4%)
2007
25M (37.9%)
2008
26M (39.4%)
2009
26M (40.5%)
2010
27M (39.8%)
2011
28M (39.9%)
2012
28M (39.7%)
2013
28M (39.8%)
2014
28M (38.7%)
2015
29M (37.1%)
2016
29M (35.9%)
2017
30M (34.7%)
2018
30M (33.9%)
2019
31M (32.2%)
2020
31M (29.8%)
2021
32M (29.5%)
2022
33M (28.6%)
2023
34M (28.6%)
2024
34M (28.4%)

From Raw DVSA MOT Records to Common Problem Cards

Raw DVSA data isn't usable as-is. Every MOT record uses different spellings, abbreviations and trim names; faults are recorded with internal codes; and 20 years of mixed-format files have to be reconciled against today's vehicle catalogue. Six steps turn that into the problem cards you see on every model page.

1

Raw DVSA Data Ingestion

559M+ MOT test records from 2005–2024, covering every UK car and van.

2

Make & Model Normalisation

DVSA records use every possible spelling, abbreviation and trim variant for a given car. We consolidate them against a hand-curated truth list of real UK models, so a Ford Fiesta is a Ford Fiesta whether DVSA recorded it as "FIESTA", "FIESTA ZETEC 1.4" or anything else.

3

Generation Matching

Every vehicle placed into the correct generation (Mk1 / Mk2 / etc.) so we can show problems at the level owners actually care about — not lumped across 20 years of a model's history.

4

Three-Tier Classification

Every problem type categorised as Problem, Wear & Tear, or Consumable (see the next section for what those mean). Non-car items and regulatory headers excluded.

5

Pattern Analysis

Compare how often each problem type occurs on a specific model versus the UK average. Only patterns the data tells us are genuinely meaningful are surfaced — small-sample noise is filtered out.

6

Problem Cards Generated

Significant patterns surface as Problem, Wear & Tear, or Consumable cards on each model & generation page — with average mileage at failure, % of vehicles affected, and comparison to the national average.

How We Classify Every Problem

Step 4 of the pipeline above sorts every fault type into one of three tiers. The tier tells you whether the issue is a genuine red-flag concern, an expected wear item, or a routine consumable — and lets you filter the data on each model page accordingly.

Problem

Unexpected failures — corroded, leaking, fractured, seized components. Our analysis exposes recurring patterns on specific models and surfaces them as “problems” when they appear noticeably more often than the UK average.

Wear & Tear

Components that degrade over time — bushes, shock absorbers, bearings. Replaced as part of normal servicing. Promoted to a Problem when a model shows a notably higher rate than the UK average.

Consumable

Routine replacement items — brake pads, tyres, wiper blades, bulbs. Expected wear during the life of any vehicle. Promoted to a Problem when a model shows a markedly higher rate than the UK average.

Regulatory & non-car items excluded

Garage errors, after-market modifications, registration plates, and non-Class-4 items are excluded from named problems. These still count in overall MOT statistics — they're simply not shown as individual problem cards, because they don't reflect the car itself.

What You'll See on a Generation Page

Every generation page surfaces problems from four distinct sources, kept separate so you can tell what's a statistical pattern from the MOT data versus an owner's real-world experience. Three of these come from the DVSA pipeline above; the fourth is the human signal from owner reports.

MOT Problems

Recurring patterns we've identified from DVSA MOT data — faults that show up more often on a specific generation than the UK average, surfaced as known problems for that model.

MOT Failures

Individual MOT failure observations from DVSA data that didn't cross the statistical-significance bar. Useful for context — these are real failures recorded by the testing network, just not at a frequency that would single this generation out from the UK fleet.

MOT Advisories

Tester observations recorded against passing MOT tests — items the tester flagged as future-attention even though the car still passed. Frequency can be influenced by driving style and usage patterns, so these are presented as informational rather than diagnostic.

Owner Problems

Problems submitted by car owners via our “Tell us about your problem” form, manually moderated by a real person who reviews each submission and clusters it under a canonical problem title for that make & model. Anecdotal — not statistically promoted — but a direct signal from owners. New 2024+ generations rely on this until they accumulate real MOT data three years from registration.

Where the Problems Land: Distribution by Category

Once classified, problems are grouped into broad categories — Brakes, Suspension, Electrical, etc. This is the catalogue distribution across every car and van we cover. Click any row to see the full stats for that category, or browse all categories.

Sorted by number of Problem cards per category. Hover for the top Problem items in each.

Why You Can Trust This UK MOT Data

Four principles underpin every number on this site.

Model-Specific Comparison

We compare how often each problem type occurs on a specific car model against the UK average across all vehicles. If a model stands out on a particular issue, we highlight it.

High-Confidence Patterns Only

We only surface patterns when the data tells us they're genuinely meaningful — not random chance. Small-sample flukes don't make it onto a page.

Data-Driven, Not Guessed

Our thresholds come from the shape of the full dataset — not arbitrary numbers we picked. Every rule is reviewed so the output matches what a reasonable person would call a “common problem”.

Full DVSA Coverage

We process every UK MOT test for cars and vans across 20 years — 559M+ tests in total.

The Other Half of the Story: Owner Reports

MOT data tells us what testers find on a ramp once a year. Owners tell us everything else.

The DVSA pipeline above is rigorous — but it can only see the faults a tester writes down at MOT time. It can't tell us about the squeak that's been driving you mad for 6 months, the recurring ECU fault your dealer can't reproduce, or the design quirk that owners discuss in forums.

That's where you come in. If you've had a recurring problem with your car that other owners should know about, tell us below. Every report is reviewed by a real person before it appears on the database, clustered with similar reports under a canonical title, and shown on the relevant generation page as a green Owner Problem card. It's the only way to surface issues that MOT data misses — and the more owners contribute, the better the picture gets.

Tell Us About Your Problem

Help other car owners — report a problem and we'll add it to the database

£

Your report helps other car owners spot problems early. All submissions are reviewed before being published.

Looking for a garage near you?

Search our directory of 12,000+ UK garages by service and postcode — every garage has verified Google reviews.

Join as a car owner — free

Get MOT reminders, a pre-MOT checklist, and tools to compare garages near you.

Create free account

Already a member? Sign in

Browse Common Car Problems by Make

Select a car make to see MOT failures, advisories and common car problems

Showing top 12 — search to find any of 197 makes.

Auto Intelligence

Your hub for tips and tricks to make motoring in the UK easier